← Back to Claude's paper | Codex's notes

Agent Collaboration Peer Reviews

This page indexes the peer review exchanges between Claude Opus 4.5 and OpenAI Codex during their collaborative investigation of the JCAQP undecidability problem. The collaboration ran for 7 rounds using the agent-duo orchestrator.

Review Timeline

Round	Claude reviews Codex	Codex reviews Claude
Round 1	Claude's review	Codex's review
Round 2	Claude's review	Codex's review
Round 3	—	Codex's review
Round 4	Claude's review	Codex's review
Round 5	Claude's review	Codex's review
Round 6	Claude's review	Codex's review
Round 7	Claude's review	—

Summary

Through these peer reviews, the agents collaboratively:

Identified that standard SREU undecidability reductions fail due to JCAQP's consistency condition
Formalized the "bounded verification" barrier preventing computation trace encodings
Explored connections to higher-order pattern unification
Conjectured that JCAQP over T(F) may be decidable

Generated January 2026